US Passport Guide · Last updated: February 2026
PixID vs PhotoAiD: Which Passport Photo Tool Is Better in 2026?
An honest comparison of PixID and PhotoAiD for US passport and visa photos. Price, AI editing policies, compliance with January 2026 rules, and which tool works better for online renewal and DS-160 applications.
Written by the pixid.studio compliance team · February 2026
Quick Answer
PixID is better for US passport online renewal and DS-160 visa applications because it doesn't use AI face alteration — which is now prohibited by the State Department as of January 2026.
PhotoAiD is a well-established tool with 11,000+ reviews, but users report frequent rejections at US Embassies due to AI retouching that violates the new rules.
Price: PixID is $4.99 (37% cheaper than PhotoAiD's $6.95–$9.95).
| Feature | PixID | PhotoAiD |
|---|---|---|
| Price (digital) | $4.99 | $6.95 |
| AI face alteration | None — compliant with Jan 2026 ban | Yes — uses AI retouching |
| US online renewal | ✓ Works (no AI editing) | ⚠ May be rejected |
| DS-160 visa | ✓ Under 240 KB, compliant | ✓ Works |
| Processing time | ~3 seconds | ~3 seconds |
| Human review | Automated only | ✓ Human expert review |
| Countries supported | 60+ | 200+ |
| Guarantee | Free redo if rejected | 200% refund if rejected |
| Photo storage | Deleted after delivery | Stored (GDPR compliant) |
| App required | No — browser only | Web + mobile app |
The AI Editing Problem — Why It Matters in 2026
As of January 1, 2026, the US State Department enforces strict rules against AI-edited passport photos. This includes skin smoothing or retouching, automatic lighting enhancement, portrait mode / bokeh effects, and any digital alteration of facial features. The rule exists because AI editing can interfere with biometric facial recognition systems used at borders and consulates.
Important: Over 300,000 US passport applications were rejected in 2024 due to photo issues. The State Department explicitly states that photos "cannot be altered using computer software, phone apps, filters, or artificial intelligence."
How PhotoAiD uses AI
PhotoAiD's marketing describes their service as using "AI to verify immediately" and performing "retouching" to ensure photos pass compliance. While PhotoAiD claims compliance, multiple Trustpilot reviews from 2025–2026 report rejections at US Embassies, with embassy staff stating that AI-edited photos are "the most common rejection reason."
How PixID works
PixID only performs technical adjustments: crop to correct head size (50–69% of image height), set plain white background, resize to required pixel dimensions, and compress to required file size (under 240 KB for DS-160). Your face is never altered. No skin smoothing, no lighting enhancement, no AI beautification. This makes PixID compliant with the January 2026 enforcement.
Price Comparison
| Service | PixID | PhotoAiD |
|---|---|---|
| Digital file only | $4.99 | $6.95 |
| Digital + prints | $4.99 + print at home | $9.95 (includes delivery) |
Winner: PixID — 37% cheaper for digital files.
US Passport Online Renewal — Which Works Better?
The online renewal portal at travel.state.gov requires: file size 54 KB–10 MB, JPEG or HEIF, head size 50–69% of image height, and no AI editing (enforced January 2026). PixID outputs a JPEG with correct head sizing and no AI alteration. PhotoAiD's AI retouching may trigger rejection. Winner: PixID for online renewal.
DS-160 Visa Application
The DS-160 portal at ceac.state.gov requires JPEG under 240 KB, 240–600 px square, head size 50–69%. Both PixID and PhotoAiD produce compliant files. Tie — though PixID's no-AI approach is safer for long-term compliance.
Pros & Cons
PixID Pros
- 37% cheaper ($4.99 vs $6.95)
- No AI face alteration — compliant with 2026 rules
- Works for online renewal without risk
- Browser-only, no app download needed
- Photos deleted after delivery
- Free redo guarantee
PixID Cons
- Fewer countries than PhotoAiD (60 vs 200)
- No human expert review
- Newer service (fewer reviews)
PhotoAiD Pros
- Human expert review included
- 200+ countries supported
- 11,000+ Trustpilot reviews
- 200% refund guarantee
- Mobile app available
PhotoAiD Cons
- Uses AI retouching (violates 2026 rules)
- 40% more expensive ($6.95 vs $4.99)
- Frequent US Embassy rejections reported
Which Should You Choose?
Choose PixID if: You're applying for US passport online renewal or DS-160 visa; you want the cheapest option ($4.99); you want no AI face alteration; you prefer browser-only tools; you want photos deleted after delivery.
Choose PhotoAiD if: You need a photo for a non-US country (200+ supported); you want human expert review; you prefer mobile apps; you want prints delivered; you're not applying to US agencies.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the main difference between PixID and PhotoAiD?
Which is cheaper — PixID or PhotoAiD?
Does PhotoAiD work for US passport online renewal?
Which tool has better reviews?
Can I use the same photo for both passport and visa?
Does PixID offer human review like PhotoAiD?
Need a compliant US passport photo?
No AI face alteration · $4.99 · Free redo if rejected
Make My Photo with PixID →